Athlete inductions recognize the accomplishments of St. Catharines athletes who have excelled at the provincial, national, or international level. To be inducted in the St. Catharines Sports Hall of Fame as an athlete, candidates must meet the following criteria:
- Be born or raised in St. Catharines
- Live in St. Catharines for a significant period of time during their sporting career
- Demonstrate superior athletic performance or contributions to their sport
- Be retired from sport for at least three years
- Have competed at the provincial, national, or international level
